Store Hours

Sunday 1 PM - 5 PM
Monday CLOSED
Tuesday CLOSED
Wednesday CLOSED
Thursday CLOSED
Friday 1 PM - 9 PM
Saturday 1 PM - 9 PM
Holiday Hours
Monday 1/20/25 1 PM - 5 PM

Location Information

Store Address:

109D Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

Phone Number:

(631) 509-6555

Our Featured In-Store Chocolate & Ice Cream Products

View the Port Jefferson Ice Cream Menu
  • TUTTLE™ Nut Caramels

    TUTTLE™ Nut Caramels - Milk Chocolate Pecan

  • The Perfect Caramel Apple

    "The Perfect" Caramel Apple

  • Sea-Salt Caramel Regular Waffle Cone

    Sea-Salt Caramel Regular Waffle Cone

  • Chocolate Fudge

    Chocolate Fudge

  • Mint Chocolate Chip Regular Dish

    Mint Chocolate Chip Regular Dish

  • Caramel Corn 16oz Bag

    Caramel Corn 16oz Bag

  • 6 oz. Sea-Salt Caramels Assortment

    6 oz. Sea-Salt Caramels Assortment

We're More Than Chocolate: Your Favorite Ice Cream Store in Port Jefferson

Though our chocolates are the talk of the town, our Original Recipe Ice Cream is another of our nationally recognized treats. Our kosher-certified ice cream comes in dozens of flavors, all of which pair wonderfully with a fresh waffle cone or waffle bowl (made by hand). With our endless customization options, you can build a sundae, milkshake, or ice cream cone that is everything you’ve dreamed of and more.

Ever wonder how our Original Recipe Ice Cream came to be? It all started in 1985 when we began making ice cream. Once we’d fine-tuned it, we knew our ice cream would have a permanent place at our candy counters. Today, our recipe is still made using only premium ingredients.

When it comes to ice cream flavors, we know that everyone has their own tastes and preferences. That's why we have dozens of flavors to choose from (with new, limited-edition flavors coming in all the time). Take your pick from classics like chocolate or vanilla or choose something bold and adventurous. When at our Port Jefferson ice cream store, ask our friendly team members for samples, then decide what flavor you’d like.

How Kilwins Makes Ice Cream Best

Our Port Jefferson chocolate store is committed to providing only the best sweets, so we developed a system to maintain our ice cream's excellent quality. The care that we put into the production and transport of our ice cream guarantees that it keeps its smooth and creamy texture from when it leaves our kitchens to the moment it’s scooped into your cone.

First, we freeze our kosher-certified ice cream in specially made containers. Then, these are transported in our own temperature-controlled vehicles. Once they arrive at our Port Jefferson ice cream store, our team members scoop them into crunchy waffle cones so you can enjoy them in-store or to go. You can also ask our team members to turn any flavor of your choosing into a milkshake. 

What's ice cream without toppings? Customize your frosty treat with our warm caramel topping or add some crunch with toasted nuts or chocolate chips. 

At Kilwins, we have everything you need to make a five-star dessert, from our ice cream to other Kilwins exclusives like TUTTLE™ Nut Caramels, chocolate-covered marshmallows, chocolate-dipped pretzels, and Mackinac Island Fudge.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Kilwins the best ice cream store in Port Jefferson?

Our Port Jefferson ice cream store is highly committed to giving our customers only the best ice cream confections. That's why we only use the finest ingredients to make our kosher-certified Original Recipe Ice Cream. Kids and grown-ups alike love to visit our Kilwins shop, and you'll often see people of all ages having a milkshake or an ice cream cone while enjoying our welcoming environment.

Our team members are dedicated to giving excellent customer service. Whether you’re a regular customer or it's your first time visiting us, you’ll always be greeted with a smile.

What varieties of chocolates are available at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

Our Port Jefferson chocolate store is a haven for chocolate enthusiasts. If you have a craving for something sweet, we're sure to have a chocolate treat that will keep you coming back for more. 

Have a few pieces of our chocolate toffee or TUTTLE™ Nut Caramels for a sweet after-dinner treat. If you're in the mood for a simple piece of chocolate, try our Heritage Chocolate bars, which are available in milk, dark, and white chocolate variants. Our chocolate confections have been loved by many generations, and we're sure that you'll discover new favorites at Kilwins.

Can I place a special order for events at Kilwins Port Jefferson?

Yes, absolutely! At our Kilwins in Port Jefferson, we have a variety of gift baskets, party favors, and custom assortments to make any occasion or event special. Please talk to any of our team members when you visit our shop so they can assist you with your order. 

What are the most popular chocolate items at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

Our guests make it a point to order their favorite confections whenever they visit our Port Jefferson shop. One of our most popular sweets is our TUTTLE™ Nut Caramels—a delicious combination of creamy chocolate, chewy caramel, and crunchy nuts. 

Our patrons also can't get enough of our creamy, handcrafted truffles and our hand-paddled Mackinac Island Fudge. Our customers also love our chocolate-dipped pretzels, caramel apples drizzled with chocolate, and chocolate-covered caramels. 

What seasonal items are available at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

At the Port Jefferson Kilwins, we offer a variety of seasonal gifts and goodies that are sure to bring happiness to your loved ones. Order custom gift baskets, limited-edition ice cream flavors, or holiday-themed chocolates to celebrate the seasons.

Does Kilwins in Port Jefferson, New York, have gift cards available?

Yes, we do! Our gift cards make important milestones and occasions extra special. For a birthday, anniversary, or any other celebration, visit our Port Jefferson ice cream store to find a gift card perfect for the occasion. 

Are there any special promotions or discounts at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

We sure do! We occasionally have special promotions and discounts at our store in Port Jefferson. Follow our social media pages or subscribe to our email newsletter to stay current on our latest promos and discounts.

Read More
Ice Cream Products