We've got such wonderful ice cream flavors that will suit everyone's taste, so ask our friendly team members for samples before deciding which flavors to have on your ice cream cone or bowl. Here at Kilwins, you can enjoy our ice cream just the way you like it. Whether you prefer a plain cone or an ice cream confection with lots of toppings, you're sure to have the best ice cream to cool you down on a hot day. 

Ever wonder how our Original Recipe Ice Cream came to be? It all started in 1985 when we began making our ice cream recipe in our kitchen using only the best milk and cream from local family farms. Perfection takes time, so we had to make a few adjustments to the recipe throughout the years, gradually tweaking it until it became this extraordinarily rich and creamy treat that everyone knows today. Once you set foot in our Kilwins stores and order an ice cream cone, you'll find out how our original recipe became the base of our different ice cream flavors, and every single one is sure to satisfy your cravings for a sweet and frosty treat. 

We're committed to serving only the highest quality ice cream to our customers, so we take special care to maintain its wonderfully creamy texture even before it arrives at our Kilwins stores. First, we freeze our Kosher-certified ice cream in custom-made tubs, then they're sent out to all our shops in our temperature-controlled vehicles. Once you order your dessert at our Kilwins store, our team members scoop the ice cream into specially made waffle bowls or cones. After that, the rest is up to you, so don't hesitate to customize your ice cream with our variety of toppings. 

As for our ice cream flavors, we've got all the classics for those who love familiar and comforting flavors. Take a break and relax at our Port Jefferson ice cream store while having a chocolate, vanilla, mint chocolate chip, or strawberry ice cream cone. Got a hankering for ice cream that tastes like your favorite baked treat? We got cake batter, cheesecake, and apple pie ice cream to satisfy those cravings, just ask our friendly confectioners for samples.   

Want to make your ice cream even more special? We've got a variety of yummy toppings so you can create the ice cream dish of your dreams. Top your ice cream with hot caramel syrup or a drizzle of chocolate syrup. Make it even sweeter with a helping of chocolate chips, or add some color with rainbow sprinkles. You deserve to have your treat the way you want it, so feel free to customize your ice cream by mixing and matching flavors and toppings. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Kilwins the best ice cream store in Port Jefferson?

Our Port Jefferson shop is known as the go-to for the best tasting ice cream in town. We are highly committed to giving our customers only the best ice cream confections, and that's why we only use local milk and cream of the highest quality to make our Kosher-certified Original Recipe Ice Cream. Kids and grown-ups alike love to visit our Kilwins shop, and you'll often see people of all ages having a milkshake or an ice cream cone while enjoying the warm ambiance of our store.

Our team is dedicated to giving excellent customer service, and we always want to make your Kilwins experience a memorable one. Whether you’re a regular customer or it's your first time visiting us, you’ll surely feel a sense of happiness at our store while enjoying your favorite ice cream flavors. 

What varieties of chocolates are available at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

Our Port Jefferson chocolate store is a haven for chocolate enthusiasts. If you've got a craving for something sweet, rich, nutty, or creamy, we're sure to have a chocolate treat that will keep you coming back for more. Have some of our hand-crafted truffles for a satisfying snack, or nibble on some of our nut clusters for a sweet after-dinner treat. If you're in the mood for a good piece of chocolate, have our chocolate bars, available in milk, dark, and white chocolate variants. 

All of our chocolates are made with Kilwins Heritage chocolate, from a family recipe dating back to the 1940s. Our chocolate confections have been loved by many generations, and we're sure that you'll enjoy discovering new favorites whenever you visit our shop.   

Can I place a special order for events at Kilwins Port Jefferson?

Yes, absolutely! At our Kilwins store in Port Jefferson, we’ve got a variety of gift baskets, party favors, and custom presents to make any occasion or event more special. Please talk to any of our team members when you visit our shop so they can assist you with your order, or get in touch with our Kilwins store for more details.

What are the most popular chocolate items at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

Our guests make it a point to order their favorite confections whenever they visit our Port Jefferson shop. One of our most popular sweets is our Tuttle Nut Caramels. Our patrons also can't get enough of our creamy hand-crafted truffles, and our crisp and crunchy toffees.  Our customers also love our chocolate-dipped pretzels, chocolate-dipped cookies, and our sea-salt topped milk chocolate caramels. 

What seasonal items are available at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

At Kilwins in Port Jefferson, we offer a variety of seasonal gifts and goodies that are sure to bring happiness to your friends and family members. Order our custom gift baskets, limited edition ice cream flavors, or holiday-themed chocolates to bring joy to your loved ones.

Does Kilwins in Port Jefferson have gift cards available?

Yes we do! We've got gift cards to make important milestones and occasions extra special. For a birthday, work promotion, anniversary, or any other celebration, we have a gift card that's perfect for the occasion. 

Are there any special promotions or discounts at Kilwins in Port Jefferson?

We sure do! We always have special promotions and discounts at our Kilwins store in Port Jefferson. Just follow our social media pages, or subscribe to our newsletter to know our newest promos and discounts.